Should I buy out my car lease? How to decide in five minutes
Buying your leased car is a math problem, not a feeling. Three numbers answer it: your payoff, what the car is worth, and what returning it would cost you.
Should you buy out your car lease or turn it in?
Buy it out when the car is worth at least as much as your payoff, or when returning it would trigger charges you can avoid. Turn it in when the payoff is well above the car’s market value and you are happy to move on. Everything else on this page is how to find out which side of that line you are on.
Your lease contract names a purchase price, sometimes called the residual. Your payoff is the amount the leasing company will actually accept today, which is what counts. Ask for it in writing, with a good-through date.
Step 1: Get your payoff and your mileage
Call the number on your monthly lease statement and ask for a written purchase payoff with a good-through date. While you have them, ask whether they accept payoff from an outside lender, and note your odometer reading against your contract’s mileage allowance.
Step 2: Find out what the car is worth
Look up the car in a used-car pricing guide, then get two or three real offers. Online buyers and dealerships will quote a car without you buying anything. The offers matter more than the guide, because they are what someone will actually pay.
Equity is the market value minus your payoff. Positive equity means the car is worth more than you owe to keep it, which is the strongest sign that buying out makes sense.
Step 3: Add the costs people forget
- New Jersey sales tax at 6.625% on the purchase price. Why the Lakewood UEZ rate does not apply to cars.
- MVC title and registration fees to put the car in your name. What the MVC needs.
- Any buyout or purchase-option fee your leasing company charges. It is in your contract.
Then compare against the cost of returning the car: a disposition fee, excess-mileage charges, wear-and-tear charges, and the cost of replacing the car with something comparable.
An example (illustrative numbers)
Say your payoff is $20,000 and the car would sell for $22,000. That is $2,000 of equity. Sales tax on $20,000 at 6.625% is $1,325, plus a title fee. Even after tax and fees you are roughly even on the car itself, and you have skipped any mileage or wear bill and the cost of finding a replacement.
Flip it: the payoff is $20,000 but the car sells for $17,500. Buying it means paying $2,500 above market, plus tax. Unless you have a strong reason to keep this exact car, returning it is the cleaner move. These are examples, not a quote on your car.
When buying out usually makes sense
- The car has equity, meaning it is worth more than the payoff.
- You are over your mileage allowance and would owe per-mile charges on return.
- You like the car and a comparable replacement would cost noticeably more.
- You expect wear charges and would rather avoid the inspection.
When returning it usually makes sense
- The payoff is well above the car’s market value.
- You are under your mileage allowance and the car is in good shape.
- You want a newer model or a different type of vehicle.
How a lease buyout loan works
If you do not want to pay the full amount in cash, a buyout loan covers the payoff, and can be sized to include the sales tax and fees, subject to lender underwriting. We are a financing partner, not a lender, and we work to get you the best rate possible for your credit situation. Credit is only reviewed if you decide to apply. Start the credit application or call (732) 618-2036.
Buying out a lease: common questions
Is it a good idea to buy out your car lease?
It is usually a good idea when the car is worth at least as much as your buyout price, you like the car, and you would otherwise face mileage or wear charges. It is usually not worth it when the payoff is well above what the car would sell for and you have no mileage problem.
How do I know if my leased car has equity?
Compare your written payoff from the leasing company with what the car would sell for today. Get two or three real offers or check a used-car pricing guide. If the market value is higher than the payoff, that difference is your equity.
Is it cheaper to buy out a lease or return it?
Returning the car costs nothing up front, but you may owe a disposition fee, excess-mileage charges and wear-and-tear charges, and you then need another car. Buying it out means paying the payoff amount plus New Jersey sales tax and title fees, with no turn-in charges.
Do I need a down payment to buy out my lease?
Not necessarily. A buyout loan can be sized to cover the payoff, the sales tax and the fees together, subject to lender underwriting. Whether a down payment is needed depends on your credit and the loan.
Can I buy out my lease with a loan from someone other than the leasing company?
Often yes, but policies differ by leasing company, so ask yours directly whether it accepts payoff from an outside lender and for the exact payoff instructions.
General information, not financial or legal advice. Your lease contract controls your purchase price and rules.
Ready to keep your car?
Call us or start online. We work to get you the best rate possible for your credit situation.
More for Lakewood drivers
Get a lease buyout quote
Tell us the car and the approximate payoff. Our team comes back with a realistic financing picture within one business day. No obligation.
🛡️ NJ DOBI Licensed
BBB profile
Reviews on Trustpilot